Investing with Confidence: Cutting Through the Noise of Portfolio Comparisons

Investing can be a daunting experience, filled with uncertainty and self-doubt. You carefully select a portfolio, deposit your money, and then wait for the magic of compound growth to take hold. However, with historical stock returns indicating that it takes roughly a decade for every dollar invested to double, it's natural to wonder if you're making the right choices with your money. The temptation to constantly check your portfolio returns and compare them to others can be overwhelming, but it's essential to approach these comparisons with a clear understanding of the variables at play.

The Importance of Apples-to-Apples Comparisons

When evaluating the performance of your portfolio, it's crucial to make apples-to-apples comparisons. This means considering the composition of the portfolios, including their fees and tax treatments. For instance, our Core portfolio has delivered an average annual return of approximately 10% after fees, based on the actual returns of our customers. While this figure may seem impressive, its value depends on the context in which it's compared. Stock indexes like the S&P 500 and Dow Jones often dominate the news, but they're not comprehensive benchmarks, as they exclude bonds and international markets. Our globally-diversified portfolios, on the other hand, are designed to provide a smoother investing journey by spreading investments across different asset classes and geographic regions.

The Nuances of Diversification

Not all diversification strategies are created equal. Even portfolios with similar stock-to-bond ratios can take different paths to achieve their goals, influenced by factors such as tax optimization, market timing, and fund fees. Some investors may try to compare providers by investing small amounts with each and then comparing the balances after a few months. However, this approach may not provide a meaningful comparison. A more effective way to evaluate your portfolio's performance is to compare it to relevant benchmarks, such as the ACWI and AGG ETFs, which track a broad range of stocks and bonds. By using these benchmarks, you can gain a better understanding of your portfolio's performance and make more informed decisions about your investments.

Putting Your Performance in Perspective

Comparing your investing returns to others can be a natural impulse, but it's essential to do so in a way that avoids common pitfalls. This means avoiding comparisons between globally-diversified portfolios and those with a narrow focus, as well as cherry-picking small sample sizes instead of considering longer-term track records. To help you navigate these challenges, we provide tools and resources, such as the Betterment app, which allows you to compare your portfolio's performance to relevant benchmarks and track your progress over time. By taking a thoughtful and informed approach to portfolio comparisons, you can invest with confidence and make the most of your money. Follow Pacsquare for more fintech insights and stay ahead of the curve in the world of investing.

Insights